08-28-2020, 08:29 PM
(08-28-2020, 07:35 PM)ijmorlan Wrote:(08-28-2020, 10:55 AM)jamincan Wrote: How about we just eliminate sidewalks and trails and make every road in the city a pedestrian sharrow.
To think about: what is the difference between this, and having many woonerfs in the city?
I have some ideas on the differences, and I think there are some, but all joking aside I think this deserves some careful thinking.
Yeah, more seriously, there is something to this. A huge number of streets in Tokyo (and Japan in generally) are de facto pedestrian streets, but every so often a car slowly rolls through them. However, there are many streets with the same design (no sidewalk) that see a much higher proportion of vehicle traffic, and these are much less pleasant. I really don't know what dynamics are at play, but Dutch woonerfs seem to be much more intentional, whereas the Japanese style ones seem more like a happy coincidence or side effect of a population that walks more.