01-03-2024, 02:02 PM
I'd love a design panel but I worry we'd find a way to screw that up as well. The biggest challenge would be finding the right people who could organize and run it and do so as objectively as possible. The one we have in Toronto has a fairly broad range of members and it works quite well due to a huge diversity of fields (architects, artists, landscape architects, urban designers etc) but this is Toronto where we have thousands of architects, planners, designers and so on and dozens of companies who work in these fields.
The issue locally, though, is that we don't have a large pool of talent to pull from who could help contribute to a project like that. There are only a handful of what I would consider talented architects at an even smaller handful of good local firms. We have a great school that teaches architecture, but these professors are busy people...trying to convince them to do even more work for free would be hard. Similarly, you'd want any panel to tackle topics of sustainability and environment, but the pool of people to use for that is not that large either. Of course you can bring in more people if you did Zoom meetings but Zoom sucks.
I just...yeah, as someone who has been involved with the design panel in Toronto, I am unsure whether we are capable of successfully replicating something like that here. There are a lot of factors that would handicap it such as our region being so small and, as mentioned, there simply not being all that many people or related firms/companies/organizations here. A risk would be that it could just become yet another unnecessary hurdle for projects to have to overcome if it was not done right.
The idea is good but there are so many issues that it has personally held me back from even attempting to propose the idea to colleagues and the city, since I'd hate for it to just fail. Though when I see buildings like this I think twice haha.
The issue locally, though, is that we don't have a large pool of talent to pull from who could help contribute to a project like that. There are only a handful of what I would consider talented architects at an even smaller handful of good local firms. We have a great school that teaches architecture, but these professors are busy people...trying to convince them to do even more work for free would be hard. Similarly, you'd want any panel to tackle topics of sustainability and environment, but the pool of people to use for that is not that large either. Of course you can bring in more people if you did Zoom meetings but Zoom sucks.
I just...yeah, as someone who has been involved with the design panel in Toronto, I am unsure whether we are capable of successfully replicating something like that here. There are a lot of factors that would handicap it such as our region being so small and, as mentioned, there simply not being all that many people or related firms/companies/organizations here. A risk would be that it could just become yet another unnecessary hurdle for projects to have to overcome if it was not done right.
The idea is good but there are so many issues that it has personally held me back from even attempting to propose the idea to colleagues and the city, since I'd hate for it to just fail. Though when I see buildings like this I think twice haha.